Film & TV Film Reviews Muse

Review: Dallas Buyers Club

An eye-opening performance from Matthew McConaughey exposes the callousness of law and prejudice surrounding HIV/AIDS in the 1980s. James Lovatt reviews

Archive This article is from our archive and might not display correctly. Download PDF
Director: Jean-Marc Vallee
Starring: Matthew McConaughey, Jared Leto, Jennifer Garner
Running time: 116 minutes

The Best Actor and Best Supporting Actor categories during the 2014 awards season have been dominated by two men: Matthew McConaughey and Jared Leto. A Critics' Choice double, Screen Actors Guild double and Golden Globes double have all landed, and with nominations in the upcoming Academy Awards in March, they're odds-on favourites for another brace.

McConaughey has achieved this acclaim for his role as Ron Woodroof, a man who, after being told he was HIV positive and soon to die, found prescriptions of approved drugs slow and the drugs themselves unhelpful. As a consequence he initiated a 'buyers club' - an illegal way of supplying unapproved (though more effective) HIV/AIDS drugs from foreign countries, for the benefit of thousands of people. Though he is based on a real-life person, the film's other main characters are not, including transgender woman Rayon, played by Jared Leto. Rayon proves to be a significant influence in reforming Ron's homophobic prejudices, replacing the friends who abandoned him amidst allegations of homosexuality. Jennifer Garner also features, competently enough, as a nurse caught up between her sympathy for sufferers such as Woodroof and Rayon and the controversial double-blind trial of antiretroviral drug AZT.

Jean-Marc Vallee approaches Dallas Buyers Club with the sensitivity and understanding deserving of such a difficult topic in history, and although some may feel a sense of relief that HIV/AIDS is presently better-understood, the stigma attached to those who are diagnosed, and to members of the LGBT community, is distressingly a very contemporary issue. Helpfully, the film is confidently constructed, revealing the plight of HIV sufferers and gradually, Woodroof's realisation that this is an issue that could change the life of anybody, forever. Importantly, though, it is alarming that condoms and safe sex in general is an avoided topic, where abstinence is instead the measure undertaken.

Where on the one hand McConaughey's performance is moving, Leto would be better described as authentically tragic, but as assured as it is, it's not the best by a supporting actor in the past year. Credit where it's due, of course: Rayon is infinitely more likeable than Ron, and more inspiring, and it's difficult enough to play a person with HIV, never mind a transgender woman too. Perhaps it's simply the want for further screen-time and character development that holds it back.

Upon other issues, a soundtrack is nonexistent and any inventiveness in the cinematography department only occurs during a bender or a pass-out. Nevertheless, the film is better off without cheesy soundtracks to pull on your heartstrings, and the film's adherence to cinematic convention is risk-free and understandable. Style is not lacking, however, as the picture of 1980's Dallas is painted with verve, a rodeo culture encapsulated and Rayon's glamour the highlight of every scene in which she features.

On the whole this is an eye-opening film that confronts HIV/AIDS and LGBT issues with an open-hearted understanding. A strong, sassy performance from Jared Leto plays well with Matthew McConaughey's profound lead, and despite being set almost thirty years ago, Dallas Buyers Club must be appreciated as crucially relevant to the present day.

You Might Also Like...

3 Comment

Vanassa Lewis Posted on Wednesday 30 Sep 2020

How much weight did Matthew have to lose for this movie ? How much has he gained back ? How could losing & gaining back be healthy for Matthew ? Just a concerned fan !


trans ally Posted on Wednesday 30 Sep 2020

it's pretty laughable to describe a cisman playing a trans* woman as authentic to be honest and I'm wholeheartedly shocked that there was no mention of this being an issue. Why was Jared Leto a better pick for the part than Laverne Cox? Why couldn't a trans woman play a trans woman?

Having a cis man play a trans woman just completely shows that the producers believe trans women to essentially be men in drag (as I've seen Leto's performance described) rather than women. Even if they couldn't find a trans woman to play the part (as mentioned hardly a difficult task when Laverne is doing such an amazing job at the moment) it would have been far less insulting to have a cis woman play it.


@trans ally Posted on Wednesday 30 Sep 2020

I share your concern. It's disappointing that Matthew McConaughey doesn't really have HIV, that Barkhad Abdi is not a real Somalian pirate, that Jordan Belfort didn't play himself in The Wolf of Wall Street and that Chiwetel Ejiofor has never once been kept as a slave. This year's awards season is a shambles.


Leave a comment

Your name from your Google account will be published alongside the comment, and your name, email address and IP address will be stored in our database to help us combat spam. Comments from outside the university require moderator approval to reduce spam, but Nouse accepts no responsibility for reviewing content comments on our site

Disclaimer: this page is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.